Let me start with a simple fact: The Hardy Boys books were much better than the Nancy Drew books. I can say this on the basis of having read 40-odd Hardy Boys books and one Nancy Drew book. That’s a more than adequate sample size if you are both prepubescent and male.
My parents learned that, for $1.98, they could throw me a cheap mystery book and I would be (mas o menos) well-behaved for several hours. This was peace and quiet at a price they could afford. I later understand this concept very well when, at the age of eighteen, I ran a small café on the South Texas border and the eatery, unfortunately, had a jukebox. After listening to Freddie Fender singing Wasted Days and Wasted Nights approximately a million times, I put a blank record in the jukebox and titled the two songs, Life After the Bomb and After Infinity. For only a quarter, I could purchase fifteen minutes of peace and quiet.
One day (evidently because the only bookstore in our small town was out of the Hardy Boys series), my mother bought me a Nancy Drew book, written by Carolyn Keene. Though I never told my mother, I enjoyed the book. I still preferred Hardy Boys books, but the book was okay. At that age, reading a book “written for girls” was like riding a mini-bike—it might be okay, but you don’t want any of your male friends seeing you do it.
I doubt that any boy ever read all 178 of the Hardy Boys books, or that any girl ever read all 175 Nancy Drew books. Depending on how you count the books in each series, there may be many more than that, since the books were written, rewritten, restarted, and issued in hardback, paperback, and graphic novel format several times. This is not counting the multiple movie, television series, and video games that have appeared since the first book was published in 1930.
That brings up the usual question: Did the Hardy Boys appear before or after Nancy Drew? Neither, both series are publications of the Stratemeyer Syndicate. In 1896, the first series, the Rover Boys, was established along a set formula: Each series featured set characters, a formulaic plot, a fictitious pen name for an author, and a ghost-writer who was paid a pittance to flesh out an outline handed to him by the syndicate. The first series was so successful, that many more followed. The Bobbsey Twins started in 1904, Tom Swift in 1910, the Hardy Boys in 1927, and Nancy Drew began publication in 1930. The latest new series from the company is the Three Investigators, which began in 1964. All of the above series are still in publication.
After the success of the Hardy Boys series, Stratemeyer approached the same publishers and offered them a new series, featuring a young female detective named Stella Strong. The publishers accepted the offer and the first three novels were contracted out to Mildred Wirt Benson. Following a strict outline, Benson wrote the stories for a flat fee of $125 without royalties. The series was immediately successful and Benson was contracted to write five additional books for the same price.
By the time of publication, Stella Strong had turned into Nancy Drew, who was a blue-eyed blonde who had graduated from high school at sixteen, and who was the daughter of a wealthy and successful lawyer whose clients frequently paid the expenses as Nancy solved crimes associated with the cases her father defended. Of course, that was the original series—Nancy changed over the decades. In the early series, Nancy drove a roadster and by the fifties she drove a convertible, but in the latest books, she owns an electric car.
Note. Somewhere, over the years, I lost most of the those early Hardy Boys Books, possibly because of how cheaply-made the books were. I gave one of my last remaining copies to my nephew, who eagerly read it. About forty pages into the book, he had a question, “What’s a jal-o-py?” Now that I think of it, I wonder how many of today’s readers know what a “roadster” is?
Mildred Wirt Benson wrote the first eight books, but when the depression hit Stratemeyer realized that, with so many writers out of work, he could lower the pay offered to his ghostwriters. When Benson learned that the new fee would only be $75, she quit, so Stratemeyer needed a new stand-in for Carolyn Keene.
Walter Kariq was an American art student in Paris when World War I started in 1914. Kariq wanted to fight, but the United States wouldn’t join the war for three years, so he joined the French Foreign Legion, ending the war as a Captain of Infantry. When the war ended, Kariq worked as a writer, a columnist, and a cartoonist while he traveled the world. He visited Mexico and Canada, spent weeks in Japan in 1935, and sent dispatches back from the Philippine Islands, the Malay Peninsula, Ceylon, India, Egypt, Italy, and France.
Somehow, in his spare time, Kariq wrote twenty books for children, under a variety of pen names. And, as you probably have already guessed, he was the next Caroline Keene, writing volumes eight through ten of the Nancy Drew series, starting with Nancy’s Mysterious Letter.When World War II started, Kariq joined the Navy, eventually rising to the rank of Captain. During the war, he wrote numerous battle reports and articles, as well as serving on the USS Texas. By the war’s end, he was an aide to Admiral Nimitz. After the war, Kariq remained in the Navy, writing history books and some of the scripts of the Victory at Sea television show. Following the war, Kariq also continued writing novels, including one of my personal favorites, Zotz!, which was made into a movie of the same name.
Walter Kariq, a combat veteran of the French Foreign Legion, a naval captain who served on convoys in the North Atlantic and the Mediterranean, and who was an aide to Admiral Chester Nimitz—somehow managed to serve over a decade in the US Navy without anyone ever knowing that he was the author of several Nancy Drew books.
One last point: In 2025, it will be 95 years since the first Nancy Drew book was published, meaning that the copyright on the name expires and anyone can publish their own Nancy Drew novel. Nancy Drew in Space. Nancy Drew CSI. Nancy Drew in the Dallas Cowgirls. You should start now.