Saturday, November 21, 2026

Your Money Is Safe. Unfortunately, You Can’t Have Lunch.

After years of being encouraged to replace money with an app, Americans are receiving startling financial advice: carry money.  Apparently, a twenty-dollar bill has several previously overlooked features.  It requires no password, never demands a software update, never needs charging, and has yet to ask me to identify every photograph containing a bicycle.

The recent collection of technological failures has made that advice seem less quaint.  Microsoft’s email services fornicated skyward.  Air traffic communications experienced problems.  Chase had a banking disruption that delayed transactions involving other institutions.  Apple experienced difficulties affecting services including Apple Pay.  Separately, these were technical problems.  Encountered together in the news, they began to resemble the opening chapter of a novel in which someone eventually has to learn to grow potatoes.  Financial advisers responded by suggesting that Americans keep some actual currency available. 

Before we start hoeing up the back yard for a place to grow potatoes, however, a little perspective is useful.  A week’s collection of headlines does not establish that technological failures are becoming more frequent.  To establish that, we would need comparable records covering a much longer period.  What has certainly changed, once we begin watching the subject, is how readily we notice every additional example.

There is a name for the tendency to collect evidence supporting what we already suspect: confirmation bias.  Once we decide that the electronic world is coming apart, every frozen screen becomes another witness for the prosecution while the millions of transactions that continue to work receive considerably less attention.  Nobody interrupts the evening news to announce that a woman in Ohio successfully purchased a sandwich.

Some of the apparent multiplication of failures also comes from counting the same problem several times.  According to the Associated Press, Chase’s software bug could delay transactions involving customers at other banks, even when those banks were operating normally.  Zelle’s network remained operational, although payments involving Chase could be delayed.  Chase said the problem was not a cyberattack and resolved it later Monday.  That is inconvenient, but it is a different story from the entire banking system simultaneously collapsing. 

Still, knowing that the interruption is temporary does remarkably little for someone standing at a checkout counter.  You may have plenty of money.  Your bank may be perfectly solvent.  Your account balance may remain untouched.  None of this necessarily persuades the cashier to let you leave with the groceries.

We have become very good at distinguishing people who have money from people who do not.  We occasionally forget a third category: people who have money but cannot presently get at it.

The numbers suggest that many Americans have made electronic access their only everyday arrangement.  Pew Research Center surveyed 9,750 adults this spring and found that 32 percent rarely or never carry cash.  Another 22 percent carry it sometimes.  Only 46 percent carry it always or most of the time.  Separately, 42 percent make no cash purchases in a typical week, compared with 24 percent in 2015. 

Those are different questions.  Someone can use a credit card for everything while keeping an emergency twenty in a wallet.  We should not turn “doesn’t spend cash” into “doesn’t possess cash.”  Statistics suffer enough abuse without my assistance.

The generational differences are particularly striking.  Among Americans aged eighteen through twenty-nine, 45 percent rarely or never carry currency, compared with just 14 percent of those sixty-five and older.  Only 29 percent of the youngest adults carry cash regularly; among the oldest group, the figure is 69 percent.  And 51 percent of adults under thirty make no cash purchases during a typical week.  Younger Americans are the least likely to carry the backup when the preferred system quits. 

This is where the elderly are supposed to deliver a lecture about responsibility.  I shall resist, mainly because I lecture young people several hours a week for a living and I already know how rarely they listen.

So how much currency should we keep?  The advisers quoted in the recent coverage do not offer one universal amount.  Tim Lootens of Chilton Capital Management recommends roughly three days of ordinary spending, suggesting that recent events make five to seven days’ worth considering.  Brian Vendig of MJP Wealth Advisors recommends a reserve covering one to two weeks of necessities, such as groceries and gasoline.  Other advice emphasizes a second banking relationship and a backup credit card from another issuer. 

The sensible calculation begins with what your household would actually need to buy.  Three days of spending does not mean withdrawing three days’ proportional share of the mortgage, property taxes, and your eventual funeral.  Nor should someone who normally spends nothing in currency conclude that three times zero is adequate preparation.

As an illustration, a household needing $50 a day for immediate essentials would need $150 for three days or $350 for a week.  Your figure may differ substantially.  Some money can travel in the wallet, with the larger reserve stored securely at home.  The purpose is access, not providing a convenient retirement fund for a pickpocket.

Small bills are useful.  El Paso’s emergency-management office recommends keeping some currency safely at home because ATMs and card payments may fail during a disaster.  It specifically recommends small denominations.  Arriving with a hundred-dollar bill when the merchant cannot make change introduces another entirely avoidable difficulty into your afternoon. 

Money, of course, is only part of preparation.  The Doc and I lived in Galveston, where we learned the hard way about keeping food, water, and candles in storage.  Living on an island where hurricanes frequently rearrange the landscape can make emergency preparedness seem considerably less theoretical.  Supplies already in the house are more useful than a beautifully organized shopping list after everyone else has decided to visit the supermarket.

This week’s Memphis coverage recommended at least three days of food and water, allowing one gallon of water per person per day, along with a power bank and a hand-crank radio.  These are modest precautions.  They do not require a bunker, a camouflage wardrobe, or referring to your neighbors as potential raiders. 

We learned about candles in Galveston; these days, I would put battery-powered lights ahead of open flames.  Food should include things that can be eaten without electricity, refrigeration, or an elaborate cooking procedure.  A manual can opener belongs nearby.  There is something especially irritating about owning dinner but lacking permission from the electric company to open it.

Then Covid taught us to hoard toilet paper.  Apparently, civilization could contemplate considerable uncertainty about its future, but not about its bathroom inventory.  There is a distinction between keeping a reasonable reserve and emptying a shelf.  Preparation anticipates your own needs.  Panic buying helps manufacture everyone else’s shortage.

Cash has limitations, too.  It cannot restart a powerless gasoline pump, reopen a closed store, or make an electronic inventory system cooperate.  It can be stolen or destroyed, earns no interest, and gradually loses purchasing power to inflation.  This is an argument for a modest backup, not converting the savings account into bundles beneath the mattress.

Economically, that backup resembles a spare tire.  Most days it contributes nothing to getting you down the road.  You carry the weight anyway because the day it becomes useful is precisely the day you cannot conveniently substitute a promise to acquire one later.

Keep the apps.  Enjoy the convenience.  But leave room in the arrangement for water, food, a flashlight, and a little folding money.

A twenty-dollar bill is an old technology.  One of its advantages is that it still works when nobody can remember the password.

No comments:

Post a Comment